Skip to Main Content
Government Leader - Managing For Results 1105 Government Information Group
 Current Issue Subscribe eSeminars Jobs About Us
Government Leader home > May/June 2006 issue



Bookshelf: Mediators, Not Managers, Unlock Conflict

By Trudy Walsh

In every workplace, conflicts arise. They can be as simple as fights over the coffee machine or as complex as warring political factions in Congress. Leading Through Conflict: How Successful Leaders Transform Differences into Opportunities attempts to show leaders how to work through these conflicts and not be stymied by them.

Author Mark Gerzon starts by outlining the three types of leaders—demagogues, managers and mediators—and gives historical examples of each. Aspects of all three types of leaders, to varying degrees, lurk not just in the pages of history but in each office or even cubicle. Each of the three types has a distinctive way of handling conflicts.

The worst kind of leader is a demagogue. Demagogues use fear to lead. They dehumanize opponents and turn them into scapegoats.

Less destructive but more common are managers. Often with disastrous results, managers define themselves by their turf. They pursue only the interests of their group and tend to be paralyzed by conflict. Gerzon uses the disastrous aftermath of Hurricane Katrina as an example of the downfall of managers. State, local and federal officials were too focused on their own turfs to work together.

But the real meat of this book is about the mediators, the best type of leader. The mediator acts on behalf of the whole, not just one sector. Mediators build trust and bridges across dividing lines. They seek out innovation and opportunity in order to transform conflict.

Demagogues created the system of apartheid; managers maintained it; but it took a mediator, Mandela, to abolish it.

Gerzon’s chief example of a mediator is Nelson Mandela. Mandela wasn’t a champion just for black South Africans but for all South Africans regardless of tribal or racial identity. Demagogues, Gerzon said, created the system of apartheid; managers maintained it; but it took a mediator, Mandela, to abolish it.

Gerzon describes eight tools that mediators use to transform conflict into opportunity:

Integral vision—seeing the whole, taking in the situation and not just jumping into action

Systems thinking—understanding the elements and relationships within the conflict

Presence—the capacity to apply all of one’s mental, emotional and spiritual resources to transforming the conflict

Inquiry—asking the right questions

Conscious conversation—creating an environment where participants can communicate with each other with respect, fairness and openness

Dialogue—an inquiry-based, trust-building way of communicating

Bridging—the process of building partnerships that cross the divisions in an organization

Innovation—the creative, social or entrepreneurial breakthroughs that create new options for moving through conflict.

This book should prove especially helpful for new supervisors, managers who feel hamstrung by office politics or anyone who wants to retreat at the first sign of a workplace conflict.







This Issue
Succession Planning

A Healthy Agency is Key to Leadership Continuity

The Sage of Change Management

Delicate Balance


 Leading Through Conflict: How Successful Leaders Transform Differences into Opportunities
by Mark Gerzon
Published by Harvard Business School Press
www.hbpress.org
$27.95 hardcover
  Purchase A Reprint Link To This Page

 Sponsorship Information and Announcements

Top Stories from GCN


 Search

 Archives
 Print Edition
 E-Letters